How it works
From survey to shipment.
Personalized curation is the product. Chase cards create excitement, but the reason members stay is that the box keeps getting more accurate.
Step 01
Tell Us What You Collect
Complete a short collector survey. Sports and categories, favorite teams, players and characters, the card types you want, hard exclusions, and how adventurous we should be.
- Takes under three minutes
- Editable at any time from your dashboard
- Exclusions are treated as hard filters, never suggestions
Step 02
Choose Your Membership
Select your monthly collecting budget. Higher tiers unlock deeper inventory, concierge curation, wish lists and enhanced shipping.
- Pause, upgrade, downgrade or cancel anytime
- No long-term commitment
Step 03
We Curate Your Box
Eligibility filters remove anything that conflicts with your profile. Remaining inventory is scored against your affinities, then a human curator finalizes the box.
- Player, team, category, card type and era affinity
- Novelty and discovery tuned by your adventurousness setting
- No repeats of cards you have already received
Step 04
Build Your Collection
Cards arrive every month. Rate each one — Love It, Like It, or Not For Me — and your Collector Profile sharpens automatically.
- Every rating feeds the recommendation engine
- Track cumulative estimated comp value over time
Sell back guarantee
Don't love a card? We'll buy it back at 85% of comp value.
When you open your box, every card is revealed one at a time. After revealing, you choose what happens to each card: ship it to your collection, or sell it back to Cardie. Sell-backs are credited instantly at 85% of the card's estimated comp value — no listings, no waiting for a buyer, no hassle.
- Reveal cards one by one before deciding
- Ship the ones you love, sell back the rest
- Sell-back credit applies instantly at 85% of comp value
How value is distributed
Across every member, we target the full value of your subscription.
Not every box lands at the same value — and that's by design. We spread value across the entire subscriber base so that, on average, members receive estimated comp value equal to what they pay. Individual boxes vary so the math works out across the membership:
$70
Some boxes land here — a solid, near-breakeven value floor.
$150–200
Some boxes hit above value — a meaningful upside month.
$1,000+
A rare few land a chase card — the high-value hit that defines a collecting month.
The high-value chase outcomes are rare by design. Averaged across all members and all boxes over time, the blended target is approximately the value of your subscription. No individual box is guaranteed to hit a specific dollar value.
Value alignment
Your box value tracks your membership price.
We curate every box against the price you pay. Every box is guaranteed to return at least $70 in estimated comp value — with the opportunity for a single box to reach an estimated comp value of $1,000+ when a chase or premium hit lands.
$70
The minimum estimated comp value you'll receive in any box.
Estimated comp value $1,000+
Upside potential in any given month when a high-value chase card is placed in a box.
Estimated comp values are based on recent market comparables and fluctuate. The $70 figure is the minimum value returned per box, not an average, and high-value outcomes are rare by design.